In the insightful critique "Why the Electoral College Is Bad for America," George C. Edwards III embarks on a meticulously researched journey to dismantle the myths propping up one of America's most controversial institutions: the Electoral College. Edwards, leveraging a wealth of systematic data, compellingly argues against the notion that the Electoral College serves as a guardian of minority rights or a balancer of power between states. Instead, he exposes how this convoluted system undermines the very foundation of democracy by potentially disregarding the popular vote, thus questioning the legitimacy of majority rule in presidential elections. Edwards goes beyond mere criticism to reveal the Electoral College's profound impact on the political landscape, illustrating how it skews presidential campaigns, overlooks small and some large states, and marginalizes minority interests. Moreover, he dispels the argument that the Electoral College fosters healthy political competition, showing how it actually incentivizes third-party spoilers and stifles party dynamics in many regions. Through a rigorous analysis, Edwards makes a compelling case for direct presidential elections, arguing that only by eliminating the Electoral College can the United States ensure true political equality and a more democratic electoral process, free from the distortions and disenfranchisements that currently plague the system.