In "On Deaf Ears," George C. Edwards III embarks on a meticulous exploration of the intricate relationship between presidential communication and public opinion in the United States. Through an extensive analysis of hundreds of public opinion polls spanning various administrations, Edwards unveils a surprising and somewhat unsettling truth: the iconic image of the president at the bully pulpit, swaying masses with eloquence and resolve, is more myth than reality. Contrary to the popular belief in the power of presidential persuasion, Edwards demonstrates that even the most charismatic leaders often fail to rally public support for their key policy initiatives. This revelation challenges the conventional wisdom about the influence of presidential speech-making and the dynamics of American politics. Edwards delves deeper into the reasons behind this phenomenon, arguing that the effectiveness of going public is largely overestimated. With a keen eye on the nuances of political communication, he shows that attempts to shift public opinion frequently fall on deaf ears, suggesting that such efforts may even backfire. "On Deaf Ears" presents a compelling case for reevaluating the strategic value of the bully pulpit, proposing that presidents might achieve greater legislative success through quiet negotiation with political elites rather than through public appeals. Through this insightful analysis, Edwards not only sheds light on the limitations of presidential rhetoric but also offers a fresh perspective on the mechanics of political influence and leadership in the modern era.